Robust and lasting growth requires reducing inequalities, which undermine the productivity and morale of working people, and limit the number of people who could participate in the market.
In much of the world, the accident of where a person is born continues to determine her life chances, education and wealth. Even It Up, a recent significant report by Oxfam, marshals worrying evidence of rapidly growing inequality between and within nations, which continue to block chances for billions of the world’s poor people to improve their life situations. Eighty-five people own as much wealth as the poorest half of the global population put together. This is a “tiny elite whose numbers could all fit comfortably on a double-decker bus”, in the words of Winnie Byanyima, Oxfam Executive Director. From March 2013, these 85 people grew richer by $668 million every day. If Bill Gates were to encash all his wealth and spend one million dollars each day, it would take him 218 years to exhaust all of it.
The unfairness of this unequal world is enhanced because the majority of the richest persons are born into their wealth. Children and grandchildren of the rich will largely replace their parents and grandparents in the steep economic ladder, as much as children and grandchildren of the poor will remain impoverished, regardless of their potential and hard work. As Byanyima observes, “A child born to a rich family, even in the poorest countries, will go to the best school and will receive the highest quality care if they are sick. At the same time, poor families will see their children taken away from them, struck down by easily preventable diseases because they do not have the money to pay for treatment.”
Many people believe that inequality is an inevitable part of the surge of economic growth and globalised technological progress. But in fact inequality “is the product of deliberate economic and political policies”, of which the two biggest drivers are market fundamentalism and the capture of power by economic elites. Both of these are in abundant evidence in the India of today. Market fundamentalism — much in favour with India’s successive governments, but pursued with particular fervour by the one led by Narendra Modi — is the insistence that economic growth requires reduced government interventions, and further freeing up markets. It opposes public investments in education, nutrition and health, and progressive taxation, and demands dilutions of labour protections and acquisition of people’s lands and forests, all of which further fuel inequality. Accordingly, dramatic reductions in public investments in the social sector, weakening of labour protections and the land acquisition law, mark the first year of the Modi government.
The other feature of elite capture of the levers of power is the unreported story of India’s public life. Economic elites buy political clout, which in turn purchases tax exemptions, land concessions, cheap credit, and subsidies on electricity and water. In India, tax exemptions to corporate India in every recent budget of around five lakh crore rupees could substantially finance India’s education, nutrition and health care gaps. Oxfam calculates that if even a tax of 1.5 per cent was imposed on the wealth of all the world’s billionaires, it could get every child into school and deliver health services in all the poorest countries of the world, saving an estimated 23 million lives. It estimates that if India just stops inequality from rising, it could end extreme poverty for 90 million people by 2019. If it reduces inequality by 36 per cent, it could completely eliminate extreme poverty.
Contrary to the widely propagated belief that fighting inequality would damage the pace of economic growth, the report points instead to evidence to the contrary that extremes of poverty are bad for growth. Robust and lasting growth requires reducing inequalities, which otherwise undermine the productivity and morale of working people, and limit the number of people who could participate in the market. Indeed public investments like in MNREGA not only extend social protection to India’s impoverished populations: they also place more disposable income in millions of more hands which spurs growth, but equitably, from below.
India today is home to the third largest numbers of dollar billionaires in the world but, at the same time, harbours within its borders a third of the world’s poor and hungry. From two resident billionaires with an income of $3.2 billion in the mid-1990s their numbers grew to 46 and combined wealth to $176 billion in 2012, and their share in GDP rose from one to 10 per cent. By contrast, if judged by the median developing country poverty line of two dollars a day on purchasing power parity, more than 80 per cent rural and just below 70 per cent urban inhabitants in India continue to be poor. The burdens of birth weigh down even more heavily on those born into disadvantaged castes, gender, religion and tribes. In the countryside, poverty rates are 14 per cent higher for Adivasis and nine percent for Dalits, compared to non-scheduled groups. In urban areas likewise, the poverty of Dalits and Muslims is 14 per cent higher than the others.
Further worrying news is that seven out of 10 persons in the world live in countries where the gap between the rich and poor is greater than it was 30 years ago. Oxfam observes that income concentration at the top fell in the first three decades after Independence, but since then for the top 0.01 per cent real wages grew annually at 11 per cent. By contrast, the rise in real household expenditure for the rest of the population rose by only 1.5 per cent. In agriculture, growth in real wages was five per cent in the 1980s, but fell to two per cent in the 90s, and virtually zero in the 2000s. No wonder that farmers across large tracts of rural India continue to despair enough to take their lives.
The ways to dam the surging tides of inequality are today well known: raising and enforcing statutory wages, expanding taxation of the rich, enhancing public investments in education, health and the small farm agriculture, enlarging social protection for the aged, infirm and disabled, enhancing maternity and child benefits, protecting indigenous and socially disadvantaged groups, ensuring water, sanitation and basic utilities to the rural poor and urban slums, and protecting the rights of workers. But in India, as in much of the world today, market fundamentalism and powerful economic elites still determine state priorities and resist policies for a more equal world. The world therefore remains one in which however hard poor people, women and socially disadvantaged communities toil, to survive with dignity remains a distant, often impossible dream.
By Harsh Mander The views expressed here are personal.
Source: The Hindu
Find out how Oxfam India is enabling communities by working to provide a life of dignity and equal opportunity for all.Get to know more about Oxfam India`s latest projects.
Read More13,Sep,2023 | Savvy
29,Aug,2023 | Savvy
22,Aug,2023 | Savvy
21,Aug,2023 | Savvy
09,Aug,2023 | Savvy
07,Jul,2023 | Savvy
05,Jul,2023 | Savvy
03,Jul,2023 | Savvy
28,Jun,2023 | Savvy
27,Apr,2023 | Savvy
26,Apr,2023 | Savvy
17,Apr,2023 | Savvy
10,Apr,2023 | Savvy
07,Apr,2023 | Savvy
04,Apr,2023 | Savvy
30,Mar,2023 | Savvy
29,Mar,2023 | Savvy
29,Mar,2023 | Savvy
24,Mar,2023 | Savvy
23,Mar,2023 | Savvy
02,Mar,2023 | Savvy
27,Feb,2023 | Savvy
27,Feb,2023 | Savvy
22,Feb,2023 | Savvy
22,Dec,2022 | Savvy
24,Nov,2022 | Savvy
23,Nov,2022 | Savvy
23,Nov,2022 | Savvy
23,Nov,2022 | Savvy
14,Nov,2022 | Savvy
10,Oct,2022 | Savvy
06,Oct,2022 | Savvy
30,Sep,2022 | Savvy
19,Sep,2022 | Savvy
13,Sep,2022 | Savvy
01,Sep,2022 | Savvy
01,Sep,2022 | Savvy
22,Aug,2022 | Savvy
17,Aug,2022 | Savvy
09,Aug,2022 | Savvy
05,Aug,2022 | Savvy
03,Aug,2022 | Savvy
02,Aug,2022 | Savvy
01,Aug,2022 | Savvy
01,Aug,2022 | Savvy
28,Jul,2022 | Savvy
27,Jul,2022 | Savvy
27,Jul,2022 | Savvy
07,Jul,2022 | Savvy
09,Jun,2022 | Savvy
09,Jun,2022 | Savvy
30,May,2022 | Savvy
30,May,2022 | Savvy
29,May,2022 | Savvy
20,May,2022 | Savvy
18,May,2022 | Savvy
06,May,2022 | Savvy
05,May,2022 | Savvy
04,May,2022 | Savvy
02,May,2022 | Savvy
28,Apr,2022 | Savvy
28,Apr,2022 | Savvy
28,Apr,2022 | Savvy
28,Apr,2022 | Savvy
18,Apr,2022 | Savvy
05,Apr,2022 | Savvy
15,Mar,2022 | Savvy
07,Mar,2022 | Savvy
03,Mar,2022 | Savvy
02,Mar,2022 | Savvy
28,Feb,2022 | Savvy
28,Feb,2022 | Savvy
20,Feb,2022 | Savvy
18,Feb,2022 | Savvy
09,Feb,2022 | Savvy
03,Feb,2022 | Savvy
31,Jan,2022 | Savvy
31,Jan,2022 | Savvy
31,Jan,2022 | Savvy
25,Jan,2022 | Savvy
20,Jan,2022 | Savvy
16,Jan,2022 | Savvy
13,Jan,2022 | Savvy
07,Jan,2022 | Savvy
06,Jan,2022 | Savvy
03,Jan,2022 | Savvy
31,Dec,2021 | Savvy
23,Dec,2021 | Savvy
22,Dec,2021 | Savvy
16,Dec,2021 | Savvy
16,Dec,2021 | Savvy
08,Dec,2021 | Savvy
06,Dec,2021 | Savvy
04,Dec,2021 | Savvy
20,Nov,2021 | Savvy
13,Nov,2021 | Savvy
07,Nov,2021 | Savvy
07,Nov,2021 | Savvy
09,Oct,2021 | Savvy
07,Oct,2021 | Savvy
06,Oct,2021 | Savvy
05,Oct,2021 | Savvy
01,Oct,2021 | Savvy
23,Sep,2021 | Savvy
12,Sep,2021 | Savvy
06,Sep,2021 | Savvy
26,Aug,2021 | Savvy
15,Aug,2021 | Savvy
15,Aug,2021 | Savvy
02,Aug,2021 | Anisha
07,Jul,2021 | Savvy
13,Apr,2021 | Savvy
18,Mar,2021 | Savvy
10,Mar,2021 | Savvy
14,Feb,2021 | Savvy
11,Feb,2021 | Savvy
12,Jan,2021 | Savvy
12,Jan,2021 | Savvy
12,Jan,2021 | Savvy
28,Dec,2020 | Savvy
22,Dec,2020 | Savvy
17,Dec,2020 | Savvy
11,Dec,2020 | Savvy
24,Nov,2020 | Savvy
12,Oct,2020 | Anisha
01,Oct,2020 | Savvy
29,Sep,2020 | Savvy
25,Sep,2020 | Savvy
24,Sep,2020 | Savvy
14,Sep,2020 | Savvy
14,Sep,2020 | Savvy
03,Sep,2020 | Anisha
26,Aug,2020 | Savvy
25,Aug,2020 | Anisha
24,Aug,2020 | Savvy
21,Aug,2020 | Savvy
17,Aug,2020 | Savvy
16,Aug,2020 | Savvy
11,Aug,2020 | Savvy
07,Aug,2020 | Savvy
15,Jul,2020 | Savvy
15,Jul,2020 | Savvy
14,Jul,2020 | Savvy
01,Jul,2020 | Savvy
29,Jun,2020 | Savvy
29,Jun,2020 | Savvy
29,Jun,2020 | Savvy
25,Jun,2020 | Savvy
16,Jun,2020 | Savvy
09,Jun,2020 | Anonymous
02,Jun,2020 | Savvy
23,May,2020 | Savvy
21,May,2020 | Savvy
18,May,2020 | Savvy
17,May,2020 | radhika
16,May,2020 | radhika
07,May,2020 | radhika
06,May,2020 | Savvy
27,Mar,2020 | Anisha
03,Mar,2020 | Anisha
03,Mar,2020 | Anisha
04,Feb,2020 | Anisha
30,Jan,2020 | Anisha
20,Nov,2019 | Anisha
05,Nov,2019 | Anisha
30,Oct,2019 | Anisha
17,Sep,2019 | Anisha
23,Jul,2019 | Anisha
05,Jul,2019 | Anisha
27,Jun,2019 | Anisha
21,May,2019 | admin
21,May,2019 | admin
21,May,2019 | admin
21,May,2019 | admin
26,Apr,2019 | Anisha
18,Apr,2019 | Anisha
05,Apr,2019 | Anisha
19,Mar,2019 | ursila
19,Mar,2019 | ursila
15,Mar,2019 | ursila
15,Mar,2019 | ursila
27,Feb,2019 | Anisha
04,Feb,2019 | ursila
31,Dec,2018 | ursila
31,Dec,2018 | ursila
31,Dec,2018 | ursila
04,Dec,2018 | tiasdutta
03,Dec,2018 | ursila
01,Dec,2018 | ursila
01,Dec,2018 | ursila
01,Dec,2018 | ursila
15,Nov,2018 | Anisha
03,Nov,2018 | admin
03,Nov,2018 | admin
03,Nov,2018 | admin
12,Oct,2018 | Anisha
27,Sep,2016 | oxfamadmin
19,Aug,2016 | oxfamadmin
09,Aug,2016 | oxfamadmin
08,Aug,2016 | oxfamadmin
03,Aug,2016 | oxfamadmin
03,Aug,2016 | oxfamadmin
28,Jul,2016 | oxfamadmin
20,Jul,2016 | oxfamadmin
16,Jul,2016 | oxfamadmin
15,Jul,2016 | oxfamadmin
14,Jul,2016 | oxfamadmin
27,May,2016 | oxfamadmin
04,Apr,2016 | oxfamadmin
22,Mar,2016 | oxfamadmin
18,Mar,2016 | oxfamadmin
16,Mar,2016 | oxfamadmin
14,Mar,2016 | oxfamadmin
11,Mar,2016 | oxfamadmin
10,Mar,2016 | oxfamadmin
08,Mar,2016 | oxfamadmin
02,Mar,2016 | oxfamadmin
01,Mar,2016 | oxfamadmin
29,Feb,2016 | oxfamadmin
25,Feb,2016 | oxfamadmin
12,Feb,2016 | oxfamadmin
08,Feb,2016 | oxfamadmin
05,Feb,2016 | oxfamadmin
04,Feb,2016 | oxfamadmin
01,Feb,2016 | oxfamadmin
25,Jan,2016 | oxfamadmin
13,Jan,2016 | oxfamadmin
08,Jan,2016 | oxfamadmin
06,Jan,2016 | oxfamadmin
06,Jan,2016 | oxfamadmin
04,Jan,2016 | oxfamadmin
31,Dec,2015 | oxfamadmin
16,Dec,2015 | oxfamadmin
16,Dec,2015 | oxfamadmin
09,Dec,2015 | oxfamadmin
08,Dec,2015 | oxfamadmin
06,Dec,2015 | oxfamadmin
05,Dec,2015 | oxfamadmin
04,Dec,2015 | oxfamadmin
03,Dec,2015 | oxfamadmin
01,Dec,2015 | oxfamadmin
29,Nov,2015 | oxfamadmin
26,Nov,2015 | oxfamadmin
23,Nov,2015 | oxfamadmin
12,Nov,2015 | oxfamadmin
10,Nov,2015 | oxfamadmin
04,Nov,2015 | oxfamadmin
02,Nov,2015 | oxfamadmin
30,Oct,2015 | oxfamadmin
29,Oct,2015 | oxfamadmin
28,Oct,2015 | oxfamadmin
23,Oct,2015 | oxfamadmin
23,Oct,2015 | oxfamadmin
16,Oct,2015 | oxfamadmin
12,Oct,2015 | oxfamadmin
09,Oct,2015 | oxfamadmin
06,Oct,2015 | oxfamadmin
04,Oct,2015 | oxfamadmin
25,Sep,2015 | oxfamadmin
25,Sep,2015 | oxfamadmin
25,Sep,2015 | oxfamadmin
22,Sep,2015 | oxfamadmin
19,Sep,2015 | oxfamadmin
19,Sep,2015 | oxfamadmin
17,Sep,2015 | oxfamadmin
15,Sep,2015 | oxfamadmin
13,Sep,2015 | oxfamadmin
11,Sep,2015 | oxfamadmin
10,Sep,2015 | oxfamadmin
08,Sep,2015 | oxfamadmin
04,Sep,2015 | oxfamadmin
03,Sep,2015 | oxfamadmin
31,Aug,2015 | oxfamadmin
28,Aug,2015 | oxfamadmin
25,Aug,2015 | oxfamadmin
21,Aug,2015 | oxfamadmin
21,Aug,2015 | oxfamadmin
19,Aug,2015 | oxfamadmin
18,Aug,2015 | oxfamadmin
17,Aug,2015 | oxfamadmin
14,Aug,2015 | oxfamadmin
13,Aug,2015 | oxfamadmin
12,Aug,2015 | Avantika
11,Aug,2015 | oxfamadmin
07,Aug,2015 | oxfamadmin
05,Aug,2015 | oxfamadmin
04,Aug,2015 | oxfamadmin
03,Aug,2015 | oxfamadmin
30,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
30,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
29,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
28,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
27,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
25,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
24,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
23,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
21,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
20,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
17,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
16,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
14,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
13,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
10,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
09,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
08,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
07,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
05,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
04,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
03,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
03,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
02,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
01,Jul,2015 | oxfamadmin
30,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
27,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
27,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
26,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
23,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
22,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
21,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
18,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
17,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
15,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
14,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
13,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
11,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
10,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
08,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
06,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
05,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
04,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
03,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
02,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
01,Jun,2015 | oxfamadmin
30,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
30,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
29,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
28,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
25,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
25,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
25,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
25,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
25,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
20,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
17,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
17,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
17,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
16,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
13,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
12,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
12,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
10,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
09,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
06,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
06,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
05,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
02,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
02,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
02,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
01,May,2015 | oxfamadmin
30,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
30,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
30,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
29,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
28,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
28,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
27,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
26,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
26,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
25,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
24,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
23,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
22,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
22,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
21,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
21,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
20,Apr,2015 | Avantika
16,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
12,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
11,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
08,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
06,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
03,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
03,Apr,2015 | oxfamadmin
30,Mar,2015 | oxfamadmin
26,Mar,2015 | oxfamadmin
24,Mar,2015 | oxfamadmin
24,Mar,2015 | oxfamadmin
23,Mar,2015 | oxfamadmin
17,Mar,2015 | oxfamadmin
12,Mar,2015 | oxfamadmin
07,Mar,2015 | oxfamadmin
07,Mar,2015 | oxfamadmin
04,Mar,2015 | oxfamadmin
02,Mar,2015 | oxfamadmin
02,Mar,2015 | oxfamadmin
28,Feb,2015 | oxfamadmin
27,Feb,2015 | oxfamadmin
26,Feb,2015 | oxfamadmin
25,Feb,2015 | oxfamadmin
25,Feb,2015 | oxfamadmin
25,Feb,2015 | oxfamadmin
25,Feb,2015 | oxfamadmin
16,Feb,2015 | oxfamadmin
06,Feb,2015 | oxfamadmin
30,Jan,2015 | oxfamadmin
22,Jan,2015 | oxfamadmin
20,Jan,2015 | oxfamadmin
20,Jan,2015 | oxfamadmin
06,Jan,2015 | oxfamadmin
29,Dec,2014 | oxfamadmin
22,Nov,2014 | oxfamadmin
22,Nov,2014 | oxfamadmin
22,Nov,2014 | oxfamadmin
22,Nov,2014 | oxfamadmin
22,Nov,2014 | oxfamadmin
22,Nov,2014 | oxfamadmin
22,Nov,2014 | oxfamadmin
22,Nov,2014 | oxfamadmin
22,Nov,2014 | oxfamadmin
22,Nov,2014 | oxfamadmin
22,Nov,2014 | oxfamadmin
22,Nov,2014 | oxfamadmin
22,Nov,2014 | oxfamadmin
07,Nov,2014 | abhij89
04,Sep,2014 | Anonymous
03,Sep,2014 | Anonymous