Related Post

Author Past Posts

    • Dec 2, 2014

      It’s a Girl!

Donate for a cause

Please fill in your personal information.

*Your Contributions are eligible for 50% Tax benefit under section 80 G

Back

Dec 3, 2014

It’s a Girl!

Sabita   /   Sabita Parida

During a field study in Madhya Pradesh in 2008, a group of women justified sex selective abortion on the grounds that poor people are saved of dowry demands later.

“Congratulations, you delivered a healthy baby girl! But considering your health condition and as your first child is a girl, I think you should try for the second child as soon as possible”, this is what my doctor from a reputed Hospital in New Delhi said to me just after my daughter was born in 2011. Despite her concern, the words which struck me most were, “…as your first child is a girl”. In an era when women lead shuttle missions as well as countries, the birth of a girl child is still unwelcome in our society. Had it been a boy, she might not have hurried me for a second child and accepted my family as complete. As far as I am concerned, the world has not been moved an inch since my birth.

In my childhood, I heard the account of my birth from many relatives and neighbors on how unwelcome I was in my family. I am the second living child to my parents. After my sister, everyone was eagerly expecting a boy. When I was born, my grandmother didn’t even see my face till I was a month old. Rather than being happy, my mother was more scared of facing derision from family, relatives and neighbors for giving birth to a girl again.

I count myself as lucky to be born, having got proper food and nutrition and not dying either in the womb or in my early childhood days. As per the last count, the Census 2001 reveals that more than 35 million girls in India were not as lucky as I have been[1]; while some of them died before age six, most of them did not get a chance to be born. These “missing girls” are victims of discrimination and negligence in accessing health care and nutrition – either when they were an infant or by way of sex selective abortion when they were still in the womb.

India’s male preference culture is not a new phenomenon; even in 1950, sex ratio at birth in India favored boys. But with the introduction of sex determination techniques like ultrasound and amniocentesis in 1980s, sex ratio at birth (SRB) in India has increased significantly[2]. Ideally, SRB should range between 103 and 107 (103 boys per 100 girls); this is close to or more than 120 in states like Punjab, Haryana, Gujarat, Rajasthan[3]. What is also worth pointing to here is that while everywhere else in the world, the sex ratio adopts number of girls as the base, in India, the base is number of boys. We measure it as number of girls per 1000 boys. Doesn’t it show how patriarchal we are?

When it comes to SRB, India has shown interesting demographic variations as compared to other countries. In China, SRB is lower in urban as compared to rural areas (i.e. there are more boys in rural areas) as agrarian societies prefer male child[4]. But in agrarian India, easy access to technology along with a predominant male preference culture, it is the urban areas that are worse-off in terms of poor SRB. This resonates in the rural areas too. During a field study in Madhya Pradesh in 2008, a group of women justified sex selective abortion on the grounds that poor people are saved of dowry demands later. One of them said, “Why not use 600 rupees today if it saves you 50,000-60,000 in future”. But if this is the reason, then how can you justify the lowest recorded child sex ratios of 830, 846, 866[5] of the economically prosperous states of Haryana, Punjab, and Delhi respectively.

The Pre-natal Diagnostic Act (PNDA) enforced in 1994 to control use of sex determination technology has been amended more than three times in 20 years. But it fails to control both the demand (the parents) and the supply side (the medical practitioners). Despite such a legislation, SRB has increased from 107.8 in 2001 to 112 in 2009. Recently, Oxfam India organized a comic workshop on inequality in Patna. One of the participants, Nida Karimi, developed a comic strip on her mother’s life story - how her father forced her mother to abort the female fetus and upon refusal to do so, abandoned her mother when she did not commit the heinous crime.

What is the solution? Some blame technology and others blame right to abortion for increasing sex selective abortion[6]. We need to look deeper as the root cause is not that superficial; lower socio-economic value of women in our society is one of the prime reasons for such violence against women. Instead of finding some quick fix solutions we need to learn from South Korea, once with the lowest sex ratio at birth has found practical solutions such as acknowledging women’s unpaid care work and increasing her participation in the labor force.

 

Written by: Sabita Parida, Programme Coordinator, Small Holder Agriculture, Oxfam India

Photo Credit: Oxfam India

 

[1] India Missing Daughters, Action Aid. Retrieved from http://www.actionaid.org/india/stories/india-missing-daughters on 29th November, 2014

[2] Das Gupta, M (2005). Explaining Asia's “Missing Women”: A New Look at the Data. Population and Development Review, 31 (3): 529–535

[3] Cbd 2

[4] Guilmoto, C.Z ( 2009). The sex ratio transition in Asia. Population and Development Review, 35(3): (519-541)

[5] Indian Census report 2011 retrieved on 29/11/14 from http://censusindia.gov.in/2011-prov-results/data_files/mp/06Gender%20Composition.pdf

[6] Falling Sex Ratios and Emerging evidence of Sex selective abortion in Nepal, Frost et. al (2014), Retrieved on 29/11/14 from http://iussp.org/en/event/17/programme/paper/2763

Content on this website is for general information purposes only. Your comments are provided by your own free will and you take sole responsibility for any direct or indirect liability. You hereby provide us with an irrevocable, unlimited, and global license for no consideration to use, reuse, delete or publish comments, in accordance with Community Rules & Guidelines and Terms and Conditions.