POLICY BRIEF

Farida Khatoon, a resident of Bhanaspati village in Sitamarhi District, Biharnow prefers to visit Runni Saidpur Primary Health Center for immunization and routine check-up of her daughter

Development After 2015

 Summary

The importance of India’s example hardly needs to be stressed. Globally, the majority of poor now live in middle income countries: India is home to more poor people than any other country, despite crossing the World Bank’s threshold to qualify as a middle income country in 2008. In-country inequalities are rising worldwide; the rise has been dramatic in India, and income inequalities now rival with South Africa and Brazil.A massive demographic shift from rural to urban regions generates new dimensions of poverty: though rates of urbanisation have been relatively limited in India,poverty reduction among excluded groups has been slowest in cities, where much of India’s growth in GDP is created— a trend that raises the question of urban poverty with urgency. Finally, with foreign aid accounting for no more than 2.8 per cent of public expenditure on social services,and a government that is the game-setter on poverty reduction, India is representative of a global context where the role of aid is diminishing.

Beyond these aspects, India’s example holds lessons on social exclusion. The rise in inequalities has added one dimension to historic patterns of social exclusion. A World Bank report estimates that Tribal people lag 20 years behind national averages on human development indicators, while Dalits lag 10 years behind. Other studies show that Muslims fare no better than Dalits; women across all groups are worse off than their male counterparts.Lasting discrimination and insecurity, the lack of economic opportunities and political empowerment combine to keep certain groups at the margins of the country’s economic and social development. Muslims, Dalits and Tribals constitute 38 per cent of India’s population,and a major share of the country’s poor. Their situation is a stark reminder that a framework for development will be of little relevance today if it does not address social exclusion.

The country not only exemplifies stark dynamics of social exclusion, it is also home to some of the most diverse policy attempts to address them: decades of experimentation with affirmative action and targeted planning for vulnerablegroups provide lessons on how to tackle discrimination. This framework suggested here draws on these lessons inconcrete terms, by suggesting 10 goals organised around the following priorities:

  • securing human rights for all;
  • addressing inequalities and social exclusion;
  • targeting the real drivers of social, economic and political discrimination against women;
  • achieving quality services for all in healthcare and education;
  • linking sustainability and equity;
  • financing the goals by supporting fair taxation and resource allocation nationally and internationally;
  • ensuring accountability.

Click here to read full Policy brief

Protecting Women From Domestic Violence

Summary

Available information highlights the extent of the problem, though the lack of adequate data certainly understates its severity. National Family Health Surveys in 1999 and 2005 are the only large-scale attempts to gather information on the issue: more than 37 per cent of women between 15 and 49 years of age reported having experienced physical or sexual violence in their marriage in 2005.In Bihar, this figure was a staggering 56 per cent; Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh and Tamil Nadu follow with figures ranging between 40 and 50 per cent.Given the sensitivity of the information and the difficulty of enabling women to speak freely during the survey, these numbers are likely to be underestimates despite the precautions taken by surveyors.

Click here to read full Policy brief

Achieving Healthcare For All

The stakes of the current debate around Universal Health Coverage in India are high. The coming months will decide whether the government takes a proactive role in ensuring access to healthcare for all, or whether the status quo will prevail. The debate has polarised positions on a number of fundamental questions. How should healthcare be funded? What should be the role of public and private providers? How should the latter be regulated? The choices made, could determine whether healthcare becomes a reality for all, or whether a majority of citizens will continue to pay an unbearable  price for poor quality services.

Click here to read full Policy Brief

The Proposed Land Acquisition Bill

A coherent policy response to the tough social questions raised by compulsory land acquisition is long overdue. Conflicts have escalated, while successive governments failed to enact a law protecting the livelihoods of affected people. The proposed Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Bill 2011 is a major step forward in this regard. However, a number of loopholes in the bill need to be addressed. Otherwise, it will not respond adequately to the sensitive nature of India’s land situation and instead, make the confl ict more intractable by covering unchanged practices under a new law.

Download Policy Brief (Oct,2012)

Download Hindi Policy Brief (Oct,2012)

India’s Mining Regulation

A Chance to Correct Course

India’s natural wealth risks turning into a curse if the proposed Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Bill fails to address extreme poverty, environmental degradation, and weak rule of law in mining regions.

Download Policy Brief (August,2012)
Download Hindi Policy Brief (August,2012)